In contemporary Western society, human rights are cardinal principles of the civil state that allow each individual to be free. What we would like to investigate in this article is how these rights are pursued in Middle Eastern societies, such as Afghanistan, which are characterised by a confessional state organisation.
The case of Afghanistan is particularly interesting for several reasons. Among them, the focus will be on the situation of women in Afghan society, especially on the symbolic meaning of the burqa and its historical evolution.
The true role of the burqa has always been at the centre of heated debates. The Qur’an does not prescribe that it be worn by women. Time and millenary tradition have imposed it as a symbol of oppression and submission, and at the same time as a symbol of the tradition and religiousness of Muslim women.
There are various interpretations, but it is clear that historically, the practices relating to the compulsory wearing of the burqa began with the installation of the Taliban in Afghanistan.
Socio-political reconstruction of Afghan women’s freedom of expression
In the history of Afghanistan, it is possible to draw a clear line that defines how the role of women and their rights in society have changed over the centuries.
The movement for women’s rights arose during the reign of Amir Adbur Rahan Khan, from 1880 to 1901. Suffering and conversions were frequent during this ruler’s years in power, but it also managed to bring a wind of modernisation to a practically new-born state.
Social reforms were adopted leading to an improvement in the position of women in society, including the right to divorce, an increase in the legal age of marriage and women’s property rights.
At this point, a dilemma arose that is as great as it is topical: how far can traditional Islam and modernity coexist in the same state?
One of the answers to this question was given by Mahmud Tarzi, a member of the Young Turk movement, who recognised the need for the Islamic world to adapt to a reformist and progressive approach to modernity. After a period of exile in Turkey, he returned to Afghanistan in 1905 thanks to Amir Habibullah, spreading his ideas and becoming the cornerstone of the Young Afghans nationalist movement.
One of Tarzi’s principles was based on the central role of education in the struggle for social reform. Thanks to his struggles, the first girls’ schools opened in Afghanistan during these years.
Further improvements took place during the reign of Amanullah, son and successor of Amir Habibullah, between 1919 and 1929. Thanks to him, inspired by Mustafa Kemal Ataturk, a new constitution was drafted that protected and guaranteed civil rights for all equally for both women and men. With these new directives, the state outlawed traditional dress codes that were considered particularly oppressive, especially for women, and also removed the obligation to wear a veil. In addition, numerous schools were opened, forced marriages and polygamy practices were abolished.
It was a true cultural revolution that, in just under 20 years, positively affected the fate of a country that was a slave to tradition and still immature in terms of democracy and legislation. All this innovation brought not only avant-garde and cultural progress, but also general discontent that led to traditionalist uprisings. These were able to overthrow the Amanullah regime, bringing to power, in 1929, the traditionalist leader Muhammad Nadir Shah. The new ruler closed all girls’ schools and reintroduced all restrictions on women’s freedom, including the obligation to wear a veil.
The traditionalist wave ended in 1933, when Muhammad Nadir Shah was assassinated and was succeeded by Muhammad Zahir Shah, son of the previous ruler.
From 1933 to 1973, the years of the reign of Zahir Shah, Afghanistan took the reformist road, fully implementing some of the initiatives of Amanullah. Thanks to this return to a more open approach, a new Constitution introduced a democratic scenario and granted Afghan women the right to vote. Universities and schools were also opened to women, thus bringing Afghan society up to date with the western world.
The flourishing era of modernisation that Afghanistan was experiencing came to an abrupt halt in the late 1970s.
It was in 1978 when the Afghan communists took power in a coup d’état and began a campaign of social reforms between traditionalism and modernisation. This dangerous balance was then broken in December 1979 when Soviet troops invaded Afghanistan to support the communist government. From then on, the Afghan resistance formed by the Mujahideen fought long battles against the Soviet army. It was only in the 1980s that some powers, including the United States of America, began to provide them with military support and equipment. Afghanistan was now at the centre of the Cold War dynamics, but it also had to fight for internal stability, which was becoming only a distant memory. In 1989, the Soviets announced their retreat, leaving a wounded country in an unprecedented civil war.
In such a conflictual climate, women found themselves living in a historical moment of social degradation: death, destruction, violence and suicides had become a daily occurrence.
In the uncertainty and chaos, the Taliban managed to impose their authority. They presented themselves as a worthy alternative to the civil war that was destroying the country, but the reality did not match the facts.
Afghan women never stopped fighting for a war that seemed to be against them.
In the national context that was being created, restrictive policies from the traditional code of the Pashtun people, the Pashtunwali, echoed strict interpretations of Sharia, Islamic law, bringing misogyny and control into society.
The right to education, to have a job, to freedom of expression of one’s ideas and one’s body, to medical care, all this was presented to women as a reminder of the years of modernisation. With the advent of the Taliban regime, the role of women was minimised and, in many contexts, eliminated.
Every woman was hidden behind the burqa and completely removed from the public life of Afghan society.
With the defeat of the Taliban in 2001 by the United States of America, women’s rights were brought back to the forefront of international debate. Following the Western intervention on the ground, the social role of Afghan women began to regain some weight.
Even in the most rural areas, the right to education was guaranteed, along with the right to have a job and to be politically active. The Ministry of Women’s Affairs was created, which ensured that every woman in Afghanistan was treated with dignity and that her political rights were protected.
Westernisation and Tradition
The main actors that made the history of Afghanistan so conflictual could be the many personalities who embraced the ideals of traditionalism, moved by the fervent need to resist the dynamics of reformism and westernisation that were sweeping the country.
The progress and improvement that were taking place in the lives of Afghan women frightened those who, tied to traditions and to an integralist and distorted vision of the Islamic religion, did not recognise the transformations that contemporary society was demanding.
Traditionally speaking, the family, being placed at the centre of social and religious life, constituted an individual’s identity. For every woman in the family, the values of chastity and modesty were essential in defining the whole household. With the reforms, this system of thought was totally disrupted, threatening the traditional thinking of a purely male society that condemned women’s undignified behaviour.
Hence, the granting of women’s rights on the Western model was perceived as a real danger, which had to be fought. The first aspect that had to be countered and controlled was clothing.
Veils and Tradition
In the Arab world, most women of the Islamic religion wear a veil.
The face veil was originally part of the female attire of certain classes in the Byzantine Empire and is thought to have been adopted by Muslim culture during the Arab conquest of the Middle East.
Numerous types of veil have existed and still exist today:
- the hijab is the most popular of the veils, also known in the West. It consists of one or two veils that cover the woman’s head and neck, leaving the face entirely uncovered;
- the niqāb covers the body entirely, including the face and head, only the eyes are left free through a slit. There are two types of niqāb: the half niqāb and the full niqāb. The former consists of a veil over the head and face that leaves the eyes and part of the forehead visible; the latter leaves only a narrow slit for the eyes. The latter, although frequently used in the Muslim world, is particularly worn by women in the Gulf States;
- the khimar is a large veil covering the head, hair, neck and chest, with the exception of the face. Some variants also include coverage of the whole body, down to the ankles;
- the chador is a long shawl covering the whole body, including the head and neck, but leaving the face completely uncovered;
- the al-amira is made up of two pieces: the first covers the entire head and the second is a scarf that wraps around the neck and also covers part of the head;
- the shayla is a rectangular-shaped veil wrapped around the head and fastened over the shoulders;
- the burqa is a veil worn over the whole body, from head to toe. The face is completely covered, including the eyes, which are veiled by a kind of net. The countries where the burqa is most commonly used are Afghanistan and Pakistan, where it is currently compulsory.
Politics and religious interpretations have influenced the tradition of wearing the veil in Muslim society. Security, secularism and communication factors have also been central to Western debates on veil. The westernisation of society, as we have seen, has led to an adaptation in the wearing of the veil for emancipated women, making it not a compulsion but a spontaneously adopted religious practice.
The tradition of the veil is so long that it is difficult to know when or where it began. Although only Muslim women are associated with the veil in fact, the practice began before the rise of Islam.
The many styles of Islamic dress found around the world today reflect local traditions and different interpretations of Islamic requirements. As a result, it is difficult to define a single tradition to fully understand the significance of wearing one veil over another.
The Muslim religious writings, the Qur’an and Hadiths, do not present precise provisions on the wearing of the veil by women. The Koran does not clearly state that there is an obligation to wear the burqa, which is extremely restrictive of freedom of expression for Islamic women.
Instead, one of the values that women and men are asked to pursue equally is modest conduct, expressed mainly in behaviour and clothing, with women’s clothing mainly covering their bodies, faces and hair.
The word burqa is never mentioned in the Qur’an, but it is included in the term hijab, which is mentioned in the Qur’an. The translations attributed to this term are veil, barrier, covering, cloak, partition, but it is interesting to note that in none of the five times it is used in the Qur’an is it in reference to the Muslim woman’s dress code.
Otherwise, the use of burqa is juxtaposed with the word khimar, found in some Quranic verses: “[24:31] And tell the believing women to subdue their eyes and to maintain their chastity. They shall not reveal any part of their bodies except the apparent. They shall cover their chests with their ‘khimar’.”
The translation of this specific verse is considered as a fundamental principle for the dress code of Muslim women. Moreover, the word used for the literary translation is ‘veil’ and this leads people not versed in the scriptures to consider it as law.
This male monopoly in the interpretation of the Qur’an leaves no room for female intellectual freedom, and she finds herself harnessed to rules and codes of conduct derived from a male chauvinist worldview. A veil worn in any form should be a personal and independent choice, free from social and religious pressure.
To date, the veil and in particular the burqa in Afghan society has become an integral part of the dress code of Islamic women. The compulsory wearing of the burqa under the Taliban regime of the 1990s and the current one has opened the debate on whether this choice is really voluntary for Afghan women. Many women are opposed to the obligation, while the majority, being subservient to the men of the family, cannot escape the ban or are too afraid of the consequences. There is also a section of them who spontaneously, without any kind of coercion, decide to wear the burqa for religious reasons.
The main purpose of the burqa is to cover the entire body, including the eyes, in order to preserve female integrity and values, while also having a controlling purpose over women and their freedom. Even girls preparing for adult life are made to wear the burqa, although it is not an obligation for them.
When the Taliban regime fell in 2001, many women spontaneously decided to continue wearing the burqa, pursuing religious and traditional beliefs that until recently had only been seen as strict obligations. Others decided to wear the burqa for a sense of security.
This is the freedom of expression on which, even today, every woman should base her personality.
Current situation
As The Guardian points out in its article Afghan women’s defiance and despair: ‘I never thought I’d have to wear a burqa. My identity will be lost’, women’s rights, morality, politics and feminism are intrinsically linked to the Islamic dress code that requires the wearing of the burqa.
Today, the burqa is interpreted by many Western countries as a sign of difference, danger, extremism or oppression for people and governments that do not support its custom. This has led some states to adopt measures to curb the use of the burqa. At the same time, women who wear the hijab sometimes face discrimination and/or acts of hostility and violence based on Islamophobia.
In Afghanistan, women have suffered discrimination and very serious violence, as has been highlighted above, at the hands of the Taliban who have used the burqa to silence any further traces of resistance within the female population.
The burqa can be interpreted as a rejection of Western values and at the same time a symbol of power of the predominant class in Islamic society. Every day, women in particularly conservative countries are forced to wear the burqa for fear of beatings, arrest or honour killings. Many of them believe that the burqa is not an instrument of submission at all, but rather a means to equality. This is because they are not judged for their appearance and are freed from unwanted advances and oppressive stares. Choosing to wear the burqa or hijab, rather than being forced to do so, is a matter of freedom of expression – the fundamental right of every human being, whether man or woman.
Another reason why women continue to wear the veil is as a matter of belonging to a group. It is a badge of honour, solidarity and ethnic pride in a world that often values Eurocentric standards of beauty and cultural assimilation.
When Afghanistan’s first small towns were recaptured by the Taliban in early August 2021, the country experienced a real return to the past, a death sentence for women’s rights.
In a country like Afghanistan devastated by the first Taliban regime, this harsh return brought fear and despondency to the heart of every woman. Most girls under the age of 30, who did not suffer violence during the first Taliban regime, now experience the suffering of slavery in their lives. Laws forbidding going out without male relatives, going to school, the right to work and medical care, the obligation to wear the burqa with accompanying corporal punishment in case of transgression: all this makes women a mere object, without rights and freedom. The right to vote, access to public office and education are only reminders of better times for those who have not managed to escape this new, but at the same time old, Taliban regime.
The Syrian poet Adonis speaks of the condition of women in Islamic countries as a problem that goes far beyond culture and tradition. This conflicting relationship between Islam and modernity is a sign of the religion’s demonstrated inability to protect and safeguard female figures in society, i.e. to condemn Islamist fundamentalism.
Today, after last August, Muslim women need the support of civil society and the international community to try not to be overwhelmed again by the culture of silence and oppression into which the Taliban are pushing them.
If you liked this article, share it!
- This author does not have any more posts.